NYT reviewer David Pogue seems a bit more enthused than Walter Mossberg about Motorola's new Atrix 4G Android phone and its gee-whizzy laptop dock. His bottom line: great idea with so-so execution.
The Atrix, then, is three things. It’s an extremely fast, powerful, superbly designed phone. It’s a gorgeous, lightweight, long-lasting laptop that’s tragically clumsy to use.
Above all, it’s a really, really brilliant idea. Here’s hoping that Motorola sticks with its team of fresh-thinking engineers long enough to produce an Atrix II.
-New York Times, Feb. 16, 2011
(Also just one passing reference to the iPhone)